A24s Undertone & Colleen Hoover Adaptations Hit seTheaters
Undertone: A24's Audio Horror Experiment
Directed by Ian Tuason, Undertone (formerly Silence) takes a more sound-focused approach to storytelling than usual for a haunted house film, focusing on sound and having minimal visuals with most of the film's audio being done through voiceover acting and foley sound design.[1][2][3] The lead actors, Nina Kiri and Adam DiMarco, premiered this film at Fantasia and received quite a bit of buzz prior to A24 acquiring worldwide rights in a seven-figure deal.[1][3] Critics are praising this film for its innovative use of restraint and are making many comparisons between the film and A24's Hereditary and Midsommar as spiritual successors.
A24's theatrical strategy is to reach urban millennials and young adult Gen Z's through a multi-format approach that focuses mainly on using a premium IMAX format to enhance the film's sonic hook, while leveraging the overall production budget to create a film that represents the growing prestige of the horror genre, yet achieves that through an emphasis on atmosphere rather than visual effects for dramatic impact. A24 is clearly embracing this business model's role as both a production company and film distributor in its marketing strategies for these films.
Reminders of Him: Hoover's Post-It Ends With Us Power Move
Reminders of Him is an adaptation of Colleen Hoover’s novel released in 2022 and follows Kenna Rowan’s struggle to rebuild her life after prison and regain custody of her daughter. Directed by Vanessa Caswill, and co-written by Hoover, the film features Maika Monroe and Rudy Pankow. It will be released by Universal Pictures within a few months of the successful debut of It Ends With Us (over 400 million in revenue). This film is part of Hoover’s journey as an author to the production team at her production company, Heartbones Entertainment.
Hoover is a bestseller with more than 30 million books sold worldwide. The vast majority of her recent sales in Young Adult Romance have come from BookTok and account for over 70% of total sales for this genre. Colleen Hoover adaptations capitalize on existing fan bases (made up primarily of Gen Z and Millennials), which greatly reduce marketing costs and help to drive opening weekend box office numbers higher than expected.
Dual Genre Strategy: Horror Meets Heartbreak
March's counter programming (Undertone Horror vs. Hoover Romance) reflects the studios' historical approach to addressing fragmented audiences. Horror films generally target couple’s out on a date or late nighters and romance films appeal to solo females or people active on social media. Both films, are targeting the same 18-34 age demographic but from opposite emotional avenues resulting in optimized cost for both through TikTok, Instagram reels, and YouTube shorts.
Both Theatrical windows must also be factored. The Indie prestige run of Undertone will provide increased premium rates for streaming rights while the release of Reminders is aligned with Valentine’s Day timing for merchandising opportunities. Ancillary revenue sources such as novels, soundtracks and branded content could result in adding over 50% to theatrical grosses.
Indian Market: Streaming Wars and Theatrical Upside
From an Indian perspective, these films show how people view Hollywood adaptations. Undertone is appealing to urban multiplex chains such as PVR Inox, with premium audio formats making it 25% more expensive. Hoover's way of emotional storytelling is appealing to BookTik, which has 15 million users in India and will create pre-release social media buzz.
There is much to consider regarding streaming. Netflix and Prime Video are competing aggressively for the post-theatrical rights to these films; in urban areas of India, the SVOD penetration rate is 45%. Local platforms such as JioCinema are considering dubbing these films for Tier 2 markets; romance films are outperforming horror by a factor of 3 to 1.
Brand marketers see a huge opportunity in this film and plan to use it as a marketing tool for their businesses. Brands in lifestyle categories will use partnerships with Hoover to market their products to consumers; audio technology companies will use the sonic signature from Undertone to promote their brands. Brands in the jewellery and fashion industries in India that have seen success from Crew will be planning product placements for the premium urban multiplex audience..
The Bigger IP Economics Lesson
The adaptations of classic literature into film create new opportunities for filmmakers, allowing them to create limitless potential by having a direct line between the director and the audience, which would otherwise not exist by purchasing the rights. A24 has been successful in the premium film industry with a 5x ROI from $10M films through global pre-sales and merchandise as a revenue source along with box office sales.
Indian filmmakers have been given definitive guidance, which is develop your own channels directly to your fans after developing your works for the public. Regional OTT platforms are piloting "Bookstagram" styles through which they can develop materials from authors in the YA marketplace to use in multiplex distribution. The theatrical experience is still the best way to create large, unique events, but the residuals from the streaming of these properties fund the subsequent cycle of development.
What Business-Minded Readers Should Watch
Colleen Hoover A24 releases will show the continued value of the new math of entertainment; i.e., fragmented audiences require highly-tailored content, yet unified fandoms generate outsized returns on investments. Studios risk missing out on the primary audiences for box office movies or television shows if they do not consider the two.
Latest Posts
